In 2013, there were nearly 4,000 pertussis cases in Texas. Otherwise called the whooping cough, this was the largest outbreak of the “100 day cough” since 1959.
That year also saw around a 12% increase of parental vaccine refusal compared to 2006, according to a survey published in the journal Pediatrics.
Is there a correlation? A review funded by the National Institutes of Health found that yes, the two issues were related.
But there’s another disease that has public officials far more concerned — measles. Left alone, measles can lead to brain damage and death. And like the whooping cough, it’s also on the rise.
The highly contagious measles virus was declared to be eliminated in 2000, due to an innovative vaccine program. Fifty years before that, more than 85,000 people were infected, according to the Texas Department of State Health Services.
And now, it’s making a comeback.
With more than 45,000 children in Texas opting out of their school vaccinations as of last fall, the state is bracing for an outbreak.
Why are parents knowingly withholding their children from vaccination? What is behind their vaccine hesitancy? They’re part of what’s called the “anti-vaxxer” movement. Anti-vaxxers believe there’s a connection between vaccination and autism, as well as other brain disorders, and are concerned about long term side effects, despite there being no scientific evidence supporting that theory.
The CDC estimates that more than 21 million hospitalizations and 732,000 deaths among children born in the last 20 years will be prevented because of vaccinations.
And an estimated 1.4 million children under 5 worldwide still die each year due to lack of access to vaccines.
But as the “anti-vaxxer” movement appears on the national stage and documentaries like Vaxxed gain support from movie stars like Robert De Niro, the risks it poses to the health of the country are no longer hypothetical.
“The reduced number of children being vaccinated in the U.S. isn’t just a problem for those children,” said Author S. Jay Olshansky, professor of epidemiology and biostatistics at the University of Illinois at Chicago School of Public Health. “It’s a problem for the country because it lowers herd immunity.”
The gradual chipping away at “community immunity” means that outbreaks could once again become routine and disastrous.
Who Are Anti-Vaxxers?
“Anti-vaxxers” are parents around the nation who believe that vaccinations are a “human rights violation.”
There’s Guggie Daily, the blogger name of a Missouri mom, and Meghan Heimer, a single mother of five, who asks in her blog, “Has there ever been a single study proving that our current vaccination schedule is safe for our children? No. There hasn’t. Not. A. Single. One.”
Across the US, less than 2% of children entering kindergarten were allowed to forgo vaccinations in 2014. But that number could be rising as parents push for broader opt-out measures. A 2013 study by the American Academy of Pediatrics found that 87% of pediatricians were asked by at least one parent in their practice to adjust their child’s immunization schedule.
“They do not immediately save a life or treat an existing illness,” Guggie blogged. “They are an optional, experimental product based on an unproven theory. Informed, consenting adults can choose to take them if they want. But it’s medical malpractice to force them onto non-consenting children.”
This libertarian skepticism courses through the anti-vaccination movement, fueling a range of conspiracy theories, even though science soundly supports vaccines and doctors, who work to keep people healthy, unambiguously encourage them.
Source: California Department of Public Health
“It is ironic that in the anti-vaccination community, the very people who are denying protection to their children by foregoing vaccination are healthy and alive today because they, and possibly their parents, were vaccinated,” Olshansky said.
The families of these unvaccinated children are more likely to be wealthier on average, with annual incomes more than four times the poverty level. On average, they are non-Hispanic white, educated, and married couples covered by private health insurance.
The Power of “Noise”
It wasn’t until 1998 that this pseudoscience found a credentialled spokesman in Andrew Wakefield, a British former gastroenterologist and medical researcher. That year, he published a case series in the Lancet medical journal that suggested that the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccines may, “predispose to behavioral regression and pervasive development disorder in children.”
The paper was received with heavy publicity and MMR vaccination rates began to drop as concern grew over the link between autism and the vaccine.
A few months after the publication, Britain’s General Medical Council revoked Wakefield’s medical license. But it was too late — misinformation had spread like wildfire and with the growing adoption of the Internet, the movement began to enter the mainstream.
In response, the American Academy of Pediatrics first produced a 21-page document in 1999 listing all of the studies that clearly show there is no link between vaccines and autism. A study of infant rhesus monkeys also shows that vaccination does not produce neurobiological changes in the brain.
Since then, Wakefield has released a documentary, “Vaxxed: From Cover-Up to Catastrophe” that was almost featured last March in the Tribeca Film Festival when Robert De Niro, a rising face in the community, lobbied for it before deciding to not include the film.
Vaxxed (From Cover Up To Catastrophe) Review From An Autistic Perspective - Last night I watched the film... https://t.co/Ms5vYdHhPV— Fiona Pettit O'Leary (@fionapettit71) August 4, 2016
Earlier this month, DeNiro and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. participated in a press conference discussing the dangers of vaccines and offered a staggering $100,000 to anyone who can prove the controversial theory.
“I think for them [anti-vaxxers] it’s ‘if there’s this much noise about it, there must be some truth in it,’” Nelson Branco, a pediatrician in Greenbrae, Cali. told The Washington Examiner.
“The internet is replete with anecdotes and misinformation that leads parents to think that vaccines have caused harm,” San Diego Dr. Mark Sawyer said to the Senate Health Committee after the 2014-2015 measles outbreak in California. “What is overlooked by parents is the fact that just because an adverse health outcome occurs in the time after a vaccine, it doesn't mean that the vaccine caused the problem.”
The Future of Vaccination
On Jan. 10, President Trump, who has doubted the usefulness of vaccines, met with outspoken vaccine critic, Kennedy, to talk about the possibility of appointing him as chair of a vaccine safety panel.
“He wants to make sure that we have the best vaccine science and the safest vaccine supply that we can have,” Kennedy told ScienceMag.org. “He is troubled by questions of the links between certain vaccines and the epidemic of neurodevelopmental disorders including autism.”
Healthy young child goes to doctor, gets pumped with massive shot of many vaccines, doesn't feel good and changes - AUTISM. Many such cases!— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) March 28, 2014
Kennedy admitted to having no formal scientific training.
“My background is I’m an environmental lawyer,” he said.”“I’m not a scientist.” But should the commission be approved, he will look into bringing in scientists with an expertise in toxicology, epidemiology, and public health.
There was no mention of consulting a vaccinologist.
The reality is a presidential commission would do little if anything to change vaccine policy. The real power lies in the states and not the federal government, which can decide which shots a child must have in order to enroll in daycare of school. The bureaucratic power, however, could appoint a new director with a new agenda.
The new administration could also push Congress to change or overturn certain federal vaccine programs, affecting funding, and stoking skepticism.
For now, those who believe in the overwhelmingly debunked theories of vaccines remain in the minority. According to the CDC, in the United States, 95% of children in kindergarten have had vaccines for preventable diseases, including two doses of the MMR vaccine. But that figure is not uniform across the country.
And top lawmakers recently sent a letter to Congress expressing their unqualified support for vaccines.
Some state legislatures are trying to stamp out resistance to vaccines.
In California, for instance, the state significantly limited the grounds on which a parent could opt out of vaccinating her children.
California pediatrician, Branco, instituted a policy in 2012 that stated he will no longer see children who haven’t received the MMR vaccine by the age of two. He told the Examiner he understands it’s hard for parents to evaluate the evidence when they are hearing so many different anecdotes, but that he wants to keep his other vaccinated patients healthy.
“I think people will fixate on the stories,” he said. “What is hard for parents to do is take a step back from the personal story and say what’s the real risk.”